Substack vs Patreon Earnings Calculator

Compare Substack and Patreon membership earnings after platform fees, US card processing and recurring billing.

How to calculate substack vs patreon earnings

  1. The membership comparison starts with paying members multiplied by a monthly charge per member. It assumes one successful US web-card payment for every member during the modeled month. Both alternatives use the same gross revenue and entered card-processing assumptions so that the platform and billing differences remain easy to see. Annual plans should be modeled in their actual billing month rather than automatically counted as twelve separate card payments.
  2. Substack’s reviewed pricing keeps 10% of paid subscription revenue and lists US card processing at 2.9% plus $0.30 per payment, with an additional 0.7% recurring Stripe Billing charge. Patreon’s standard plan is 10% for creators publishing after August 4, 2025, plus the listed US card processing. Legacy Patreon arrangements may differ, so each platform percentage is editable. The billing percentage in this calculator belongs only to the Substack alternative.
  3. The result shows gross revenue, total transaction-related fees and estimated net receipts for each platform. Your entered payout cost is subtracted once from each alternative, not once per member. The $0 initial payout cost is an unverified assumption, not a statement that all withdrawal methods are free. The comparison excludes sales tax, conversion charges, app-store purchases, refunds and operating expenses, and it cannot predict whether your audience will convert equally well on either platform.

Formula: gross = members * price; cardFees = gross * cardPct / 100 + members * fixed; SubstackNet = gross - gross * (SubstackPct + billingPct) / 100 - cardFees - payout; PatreonNet = gross - gross * PatreonPct / 100 - cardFees - payout

Formula

gross = members * price; cardFees = gross * cardPct / 100 + members * fixed; SubstackNet = gross - gross * (SubstackPct + billingPct) / 100 - cardFees - payout; PatreonNet = gross - gross * PatreonPct / 100 - cardFees - payout

Where:

Dollar inputs
= USD amounts on the same transaction or period basis described above
Percent inputs
= Editable percentage points, divided by 100 for calculation

Worked example

With 100 members paying $10 monthly, gross revenue is $1,000. At 2.9% plus $0.30 per payment, card processing costs $29 plus $30, or $59. Substack’s 10% fee is $100 and the 0.7% billing amount is $7. With no entered payout cost, estimated Substack net revenue is $834.

At the same membership level, Patreon’s entered 10% platform fee and $59 processing leave $841 before any payout charge. For a separate legacy-rate example, ten members paying $20 produce $200 gross. With Patreon entered at 8% and a $1 payout cost on each alternative, Patreon net is $174.20 and Substack net is $168.80.

Separating membership fees from audience strategy

Start with successful payments rather than your total email list or follower count. Free readers do not generate subscription fees, and failed charges do not behave like collected cash. Review a month with a reasonably stable membership base and compare the processing line with the count of actual payments. Small monthly pledges can make fixed transaction charges especially important relative to revenue.

Keep platform choice separate from pricing experiments. First compare the same membership and charge on both services to understand the fee difference. Then test a different price while acknowledging that member demand may change. Budget editorial work, community moderation, premium fulfillment and taxes outside this receipt estimate, and remember that a projected monthly net is not the same as cash already available for withdrawal.

Frequently asked questions

The reviewed Substack support page lists a recurring Stripe Billing percentage in addition to its platform fee and card processing. The calculator therefore applies that entered percentage only to Substack revenue. If your agreement or payment method differs, adjust the assumption rather than deleting the charge from your budget without checking.

Related calculators

Illustrative US estimate only. Verify account-specific rates, fee bases and eligibility with the provider. Editable defaults are not guarantees. Taxes and unlisted charges are excluded.